Influencer Marketing Isn't Dead

ately, LinkedIn has been flooded with posts boldly claiming that influencer marketing is dead. Honestly? That take is just silly. Influencer marketing isn’t a passing trend. It’s not a gimmick. It’s human nature. We’ve always been influenced by others — people with status, beauty, charisma, authority, or relatability. That’s not marketing. That’s biology.

Influence Is Timeless

Think about it.

The earliest influencers weren’t brand ambassadors or Instagram stars. They were tribal leaders, spiritual guides, and royalty — the people whose opinions shaped tribes, communities, and entire nations.

Then came celebrities — actors, athletes, and musicians who dominated traditional media. Their endorsements were gospel.

Now? Influence belongs to creators and everyday people with a smartphone, a story, and a community. Whether it’s a Gen Z skincare guru on TikTok or a dad reviewing camping gear on YouTube, the format may have changed, but the core dynamic hasn’t.

Influencer marketing is just the modern label for a timeless force. It has adapted to platforms and evolved with our behaviors, but it’s not going away. It’s shifting, and smart brands are shifting with it.

What Is Dying: Outdated Execution

What’s dying is not influencer marketing itself — it’s the way some brands still approach it.

If your influencer marketing playbook still looks like this:

• Writing rigid scripts that strip creators of their authentic voice
• Choosing partners based solely on follower count
• Tracking outreach in a clunky Google Sheet like it’s 2018
• Measuring success only by likes and impressions, not actual conversions or engagement

Then, yes — your version of influencer marketing is dead. And it should be.

Because we’re in an era of algorithmic noise, AI-generated content, and manufactured authenticity, consumers are savvy — they know when they’re being sold to. They don’t just want to be impressed; they want to be moved.

The New Rules of Influence

If you want to break through the clutter and really engage with people, you need to think differently. That means going beyond vanity metrics and measuring meaningful engagement. Build relationships, not just reach. Here's how:

1. Real People > Polished Ads

The most powerful endorsements don’t come from perfection — they come from people we trust.

Take Topicals, a skin care brand. Rather than pursuing mega-influencers, they work with micro-creators who discuss acne, anxiety, and honest-to-goodness skin struggles. It's raw, it's unfiltered, and it resonates. Their comment sections aren't full of emojis — they're full of stories.

Another case in point is Glossier, which constructed its brand to a great extent by making customers into ambassadors. No high-gloss campaigns. Just authentic people, discussing authentic routines.

2. Emotion > Aesthetics

Pretty content is everywhere. But content that makes you feel something? That’s rare.

Look at Duolingo’s TikTok. It’s not polished. It’s downright chaotic. But it’s hilarious, self-aware, and emotionally resonant with its Gen Z audience — and it works. It doesn’t feel like marketing. It feels like a character you know.

Influencer campaigns that focus on relatability, humor, vulnerability, or shared values outperform ones that simply show a perfect product in a perfect setting.

3. Social Proof > Star Power

A creator with 3,000 deeply engaged followers often drives more sales than one with 300,000 passive ones. That’s because influence is about trust, not just traffic.

BookTok is a great example — a community of everyday readers who’ve turned unknown novels into bestsellers overnight, not because of glossy ads, but because of heartfelt, grassroots recommendations.

In the same vein, a niche fashion YouTuber recommending a sustainable shoe brand with enthusiasm and transparency can outperform a celebrity shoutout that feels paid and performative.

4. Creators Are Partners, Not Ad Slots

The best creator partnerships happen when brands collaborate, not dictate. Treat creators like artists, not employees.

They know their audience. They know what resonates. Let them have creative freedom — because when creators are excited about what they’re making, their followers can feel it. The worst-performing content? Posts where creators clearly read off a script, hold up a product, and smile stiffly. The best-performing content? Posts that feel like a friend sharing something they genuinely love.

Today's audiences are intelligent. They swipe through ads in seconds, but they'll pause for a story that resonates. That's why the most effective partnerships are grounded in trust — not only between brand and creator, but between creator and audience.

5. Stay Close to Culture

Platforms change. Algorithms alter. But influence persists — if you remain attuned to how people are speaking, creating, and consuming.

The 2025 winners are the brands that speak internet culture. They don't simply "appear on TikTok." They get the intricacies of trends, memes, and creator behavior. They bring on strategists who reside on Reddit. They test and learn never-endingly.

They realize that influence in today's world isn't perfect — it's participatory.

Final Thoughts

Influencer marketing isn’t dead. But lazy, outdated, transactional influencer marketing? That’s on life support.

The future belongs to brands that:

• Respect creators as partners, not mouthpieces
• Value authenticity over vanity metrics
• Build community, not just campaigns
• Invest in long-term relationships, not one-off transactions
• Understand that trust is earned, not bought

Because in a world overwhelmed by content, what truly influences people is still the same: real humans, telling real stories, in real ways.

Ready to level up your creator marketing?

Let’s build something real — together.

‍